top of page
HCL Review
HCI Academy Logo
Foundations of Leadership
DEIB
Purpose-Driven Workplace
Creating a Dynamic Organizational Culture
Strategic People Management Capstone

Why Leaders Need to Overcome the Psychology of Thinking They're Right - Even When They're Wrong

Writer's picture: Jonathan H. Westover, PhDJonathan H. Westover, PhD

It is clear that many people struggle with the psychology of thinking they are right, even when they are wrong. This cognitive bias can lead to individuals making decisions that are not in their best interest or the best interest of their organization. Leaders, in particular, need to be aware of this bias and learn to overcome it to make informed and effective decisions that benefit their organizations and stakeholders.


The Psychology of Why You Think You're Right - Even if You're Wrong


The psychology of why people think they're right even when they're wrong is rooted in cognitive biases. These biases refer to the brain's tendency to make judgments and decisions that are influenced by pre-existing beliefs, attitudes, and experiences.


One cognitive bias that could explain this phenomenon is confirmation bias, which is the tendency to search for, interpret, and remember information in a way that confirms one's pre-existing beliefs. When we encounter new information, we tend to scrutinize it more if it goes against our beliefs, and we are more likely to accept it if it supports our beliefs.


Another cognitive bias that could contribute to people thinking they're right even when they're wrong is the Dunning-Kruger effect. This effect refers to the tendency for people who lack knowledge or expertise in a particular area to overestimate their abilities and knowledge, while also underestimating the abilities and knowledge of others. This can lead individuals to be overly confident in their beliefs and opinions, even when they are not supported by evidence or expertise.


To overcome these biases, individuals need to be aware of them and actively work to challenge their own beliefs and seek out diverse perspectives and information. It also helps to cultivate a growth mindset, which is the belief that one's abilities and intelligence can be developed through hard work and dedication. This mindset encourages individuals to see challenges and mistakes as opportunities for learning and growth, rather than as threats to their self-worth or intelligence.


How to Challenge Your Beliefs


Challenging one's beliefs can be a difficult but rewarding process. One effective way to do this is by seeking out information and perspectives that are different from one's own. For instance, if an individual strongly believes in a particular political ideology, they could seek out news sources or individuals who hold opposing views and try to understand their perspectives. This can help to broaden one's understanding of complex issues and challenge one's assumptions and biases.


Another way to challenge one's beliefs is to engage in critical thinking. This involves questioning assumptions, evaluating evidence, and considering alternative explanations. For instance, if an individual strongly believes that a particular product is the best on the market, they could research and compare it to similar products, read reviews from different sources, and consider the pros and cons of each option. This can help to challenge one's biases and lead to more informed and nuanced beliefs.


Ultimately, challenging one's beliefs requires a willingness to be open-minded, curious, and humble. It can be uncomfortable and even unsettling to confront one's biases and assumptions, but it is a necessary step towards personal and intellectual growth.


Overcoming the Discomfort of Challenging Your Beliefs


Overcoming the discomfort of challenging one's beliefs requires a growth mindset and a willingness to embrace discomfort. Here are a few strategies that can help:


  1. Practice mindfulness: Mindfulness is the practice of being present and non-judgmental. By cultivating mindfulness, individuals can learn to observe their thoughts and emotions without getting caught up in them. This can help to reduce the discomfort that comes with challenging one's beliefs.

  2. Seek support: Challenging one's beliefs can be a lonely and isolating experience. It can be helpful to seek out a trusted friend, family member, or mentor who can provide support and encouragement.

  3. Embrace uncertainty: Challenging one's beliefs often means confronting uncertainty and ambiguity. By embracing uncertainty and recognizing that it is a natural part of the learning process, individuals can reduce their discomfort and anxiety.

  4. Take small steps: Challenging one's beliefs can feel overwhelming, especially if they are deeply ingrained. By taking small steps and setting achievable goals, individuals can build confidence and momentum.


Ultimately, overcoming the discomfort of challenging one's beliefs requires a mindset shift. It requires individuals to recognize that discomfort is a natural part of the learning process and that growth requires stepping outside of one's comfort zone. With practice and persistence, individuals can learn to embrace discomfort and use it as a catalyst for personal and professional growth.


Why this Is Important for Leaders


It is crucial for leaders to recognize why they may think they're right, even when they're wrong. This is because leaders have a significant impact on the culture and performance of their organizations, and their beliefs and biases can influence the decisions they make and the actions they take.


When leaders are unable to recognize their biases and challenge their beliefs, they may make decisions that are not in the best interests of their organization or stakeholders. They may also create a culture that is resistant to change, innovation, and diversity of thought. This can limit the organization's ability to adapt to changing market conditions, respond to emerging trends, and attract and retain top talent.


On the other hand, leaders who are able to recognize their biases and challenge their beliefs are better equipped to make informed and effective decisions. They are also more likely to create a culture that values curiosity, critical thinking, and continuous learning. This can lead to increased innovation, collaboration, and employee engagement, which can ultimately drive organizational success.


In short, leaders who learn to recognize why they think they're right, even when they're wrong, are better equipped to lead their organizations through complex and uncertain times. They are able to make informed decisions, create a culture of learning and growth, and achieve long-term success.


How Leaders Can Learn to Overcome Thinking They Are Right, Even When They Are Wrong


Leaders can learn to overcome thinking they are right, even when they are wrong, by following these steps:


  1. Cultivate self-awareness: Leaders need to be self-aware and understand their own biases and assumptions. This can be achieved through reflection, feedback from others, and psychometric assessments.

  2. Encourage diverse perspectives: Leaders need to create an organizational culture that values and encourages diverse perspectives. This can be achieved by hiring a diverse workforce, fostering open communication, and creating opportunities for collaboration and teamwork.

  3. Challenge assumptions: Leaders need to be willing to challenge their own assumptions and beliefs. This can be achieved by seeking out alternative viewpoints, considering multiple options, and evaluating evidence objectively.

  4. Foster a learning culture: Leaders need to create a culture of continuous learning and growth. This can be achieved by providing training and development opportunities, recognizing and rewarding innovation and creativity, and embracing failure as a learning opportunity.

  5. Seek feedback: Leaders need to seek feedback from their peers, employees, and stakeholders. This can be achieved through regular check-ins, surveys, and 360-degree feedback.


By following these steps, leaders can learn to recognize when they are wrong, overcome their biases and assumptions, and make informed and effective decisions that benefit their organizations and stakeholders.


Conclusion


The psychology of thinking you are right, even when you are wrong, is a common cognitive bias that can have significant consequences for individuals and organizations. Overcoming this bias requires self-awareness, a willingness to challenge assumptions, and a commitment to creating a culture of learning and growth. By following these steps, leaders can make informed and effective decisions that benefit their organizations and stakeholders, and achieve long-term success.

Human Capital Leadership Review

eISSN 2693-9452 (online)

Subscription Form

HCI Academy Logo
Effective Teams in the Workplace
Employee Well being
Fostering Change Agility
Servant Leadership
Strategic Organizational Leadership Capstone
bottom of page